Please deactivate your ad blocker in order to see our subscription offer, (Image credit: Joakim Boren (Mulroy Architects)), Kristin Ess 3-in-One Flat Iron - 1 1/4": Review, The Chi Spin n Curl is my favorite hair tool I've ever owned—and it's 30 percent off right now, Friluftsliv is the new Hygge, and it's the key to getting through winter, Best projectors: 10 top options for a cinematic experience at home, 14 picks from Wayfair's Kelly Clarkson Home that'll elevate your decor AND help you find your aesthetic, 8 best food gift baskets for Christmas 2020, Christmas foods dangerous to dogs: how to keep your pooch safe this festive season, Mulled wine recipe – a classic winter cocktail for cozy evenings, The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, Planning and costing a single storey extension. Party wall agreements are generally enforceable as covenants running with the land, so that future owners or assignees are bound by the agreement. Party Wall: In real estate, a shared wall that separates housing units. In addition to shared walls inside a home or condo, party walls also include those attached and adjacent to the property (like fences for example) that run through your yard and are on both properties, or anything else that might be standing on the land of two or more owners, whether that’s a wall or some other shared structure. This could give them the right to seek an injunction to have your proposed development reduced in size or to seek a payment to compensate for the reduction of light. That said, certainly a prospective buyer can refuse the party wall agreement, if of course, they’re refusing to buy or rent the property in the first place. You will still have to comply with the terms of the Act, for example avoiding unnecessary inconvenience, providing temporary protection for adjacent buildings and properties where necessary and compensating your neighbour for any loss or damage if it is caused by the work. Company. Party walls can be a non-structural wall, but laws in various jurisdictions outline requirements for how party walls must be constructed. By including the party wall agreement in the public records, prospective buyers looking at a property with a party wall can understand better the property they are considering purchasing. You can use this party wall template letter from the HomeOwners Alliance to send to your neighbours. A party wall agreement is governed by the Party wall act, 1996. It may also include routine maintenance and the construction of other improvements such as fences and sheds in connection with the party wall. In addition to shared walls inside a home or condo, party walls also include those attached and adjacent to the property (like fences for example) that run through your yard and are on both properties, or anything else that might be standing on the land of two or more owners, whether that’s a wall or some other shared structure. The uplifting Nordic concept is the perfect antidote to the long, dark winter months on the horizon, By Kaitlyn McInnis • This article will cover some essential information to get you started. Party wall agreements are pretty obvious. If the local authority decide to take enforcement action, you are advised to comply with this, as contravention can lead to prosecution. The beauty of a party wall agreement is that you have a legal document that lays out how all issues that involve a common wall will be handled, without having to pay a Home Owners Association to enforce it. All the details on party walls and if and when you need a party wall agreement can be found in the Party Wall etc. 2020-12-08T17:32:23Z. Party wall agreements are important whenever a property has a wall that is shared by multiple properties. By giving your neighbour notice, you are effectively asking for their permission to go ahead. The same applies if you have a party wall agreement with your neighbours but fail to observe the terms agreed. The party wall agreement should define clearly which party is obligated to maintain the wall, as well as the repercussions if that wall is not maintained. Any agreement you reach should be in writing. Your neighbour has 14 days to respond and give their consent, or request a party wall settlement. A party wall (occasionally parti-wall or parting wall, also known as common wall or as a demising wall) is a dividing partition between two adjoining buildings that is shared by the occupants of each residence or business.Typically, the builder lays the wall along a property line dividing two terraced houses, so that one half of the wall's thickness lies on each side. Party wall easements are terminated on the accidental destruction of the wall and, under some circumstances, on substantial changes in conditions of the neighborhood. A party wall agreement takes account of these traditional principles and stipulates rules around ownership and maintenance obligations for the shared party wall. Party walls often are seen and taken for granted, particularly in rental units, where you know you’re already sharing a wall or two with your neighbors. Your neighbours may seek compensation if they can prove they have suffered a loss as a result of the work, and it could even require removal of the work. The Party Wall Act 1996 is designed to help you undertake work – providing access to neighbouring properties – while protecting the interests of your neighbours. in your condo, townhouse, apartment complex, then typically it can’t be refused when a tenant/owner moves in, since it likely already is in place for other units. Before you can build a new wall right next to your neighbor, you need to hand them a party wall notice, and as soon as you are granted permission, each of you shall sign a Party Wall Agreement Form. When an issue with a shared wall takes place, suddenly everybody is concerned, and here is where there will be difficulties, particularly if there is no agreement. A party structure is a wall or floor separating buildings or parts of a building – for example, between flats or maisonettes. The parties can agree that the wall is to be located on land owned entirely by one of them or that it is to stand partly, usually equally, on both parcels. In real estate, a party wall is a shared wall that separates two separately rented or owned units. This will delay your project and is likely to increase your costs – your builder may demand compensation for the time they cannot work, or may start another job and not return for several months. It’s always a good idea to discuss proposals in advance of serving notice. This includes complaints about noise and dust from building work where it unreasonably interferes with the use or enjoyment of their premises or is prejudicial to their health. Party walls are sometimes built with additional insulation, so that sound (the “party” for example) from an adjoining unit does not disturb neighbors. Adjoining Landowners can enter into a contract to build a party wall. But, if you’re more of a risk-taker, you should still create a party wall agreement. Find letter templates and more information on giving notice in the party wall explanatory booklet. That’s not always an ideal situation. Once owners legally consent to the terms involved, party wall agreements are recorded in the land records, whether (typically) at the county clerk or somewhere else. Give a food gift basket to someone you love this Christmas – they're cheaper than buying a hamper! Party walls are most commonly found in apartments, condominiums and office complexes, where different tenants share a common structure. Adjoining owners can agree or disagree with what is proposed. Additionally, if two people are building a new party wall agreement together, then of course there will be some refusal and compromise as the party wall agreement is constructed for the first time. Country. You need to pay for any building works that you start on a party wall. If building work affects a party structure, you must serve notice at least two months before work begins. But the Chi Spin n Curl delivers gorgeous, bouncy curls and requires no skill whatsoever. Only then will you need to go about arranging a party wall agreement, and look into getting surveyors onboard. If you get your neighbour on board, they may simply consent to the work (but you’ll need this in writing) and you’ll incur no fees. In England and Wales, a right to light is usually acquired by prescription – in other words, once light has been enjoyed for an uninterrupted period of 20 years through the windows of the building. A Party Wall Agreement (technically called an “ award ”) is the document produced by the two party wall surveyors (or the “agreed surveyor”) which resolves the dispute that was triggered when the party wall notice was not consented to. Once owners legally consent to the terms involved, party wall agreements are recorded in the land records, whether (typically) at the county clerk or somewhere else. But think of row houses and commercial structures sharing walls. If you're a property owner who has agreed minor repair works with a neighbour of a shared boundary, you'll need a party wall agreement for repairs. Definition of a party fence wall. Retrospective Party Wall Agreement. Previous : Work you must tell your neighbour about A matter of a few hundred can escalate into many thousands in court because an agreement couldn’t be reach between two ‘friends’. Additionally, if two people are building a new party wall agreement together, then of course there will be some refusal and compromise as the party wall agreement is constructed for the first time. Can you do a party wall agreement yourself. And typically, a party wall agreement requires the owners to maintain their portion of the wall together and in concert. The Party Wall etc Act 1996 provides a framework for preventing and resolving disputes in relation to party walls, boundary walls and excavations near neighbouring buildings.A building owner proposing to start work covered by the Act must give adjoining owners notice of their intentions in the way set down in the Act. by Christopher Stjernholm | Apr 13, 2020 | Real Estate Glossary. 3 Party Wall Agreement Form free download. It will usually consist of three parts: A party fence wall is a wall which stands on the land of different owners and is used for separating adjoining lands but does not form part of a building. But, if you’re more of a risk-taker, you should still create a party wall agreement. And then hopefully, the agreement also stipulates that for one party to make structural changes to the party wall, it would require the consent of both parties, which of course makes sense since both owners share the wall, and any structural changes would necessarily affect both owners. If you happen to live in a home that has a party wall, chances are when it comes to refinance if you don’t have a party wall agreement, it may come up as an issue. However, if you have built without consideration for your neighbour’s right to light and are found to have infringed their right, the court has the power to have the building altered or removed at your expense. Party Wall DIY is a party wall notice generator designed to help you getting to a party wall agreement without a surveyor.The tool will also make sure your notices comply with the Party Wall Etc. It may also include. The most commonly used rights granted are: While failing to observe the act is not an offence, your neighbours can take civil action against you and have an injunction issued to stop further work until a party wall agreement is arranged. United Kingdom Spain Netherlands France United States. Tell us whether you accept cookies. We use cookies to collect information about how you use GOV.UK. Unfortunately, the definition is way more boring than that, even though sometimes, late at night, when you’re trying to sleep, you can hear a party going on … on the other side of the wall. First off, it’s better to be safe than sorry, right? What is a Retrospective Party Wall Arrangement ? They may write to you and issue a counter-notice, requesting certain alterations to the work, or set conditions such as working hours. Party walls often are seen and taken for granted, particularly in rental units, where you know you’re already sharing a wall or two with your neighbors. A party wall settlement - technically called a party wall agreement - is made between these owners regarding any building work that may affect either side of the boundary. A party wall agreement is only needed if your neighbour doesn’t give consent, or doesn’t respond to, your notice within 14 days. These Christmas foods can make your dog very sick, so make sure you keep them well out of reach of your pet, Spiced, citrusy and just delicious, this is the only mulled wine recipe you will ever need. It therefore pays to contact your neighbours first to discuss your proposals and to try to overcome any issues in advance, or at the very least ensure they receive the notice and respond within 14 days, because if they fail to, they are deemed to be in dispute and you will need to instruct a surveyor anyway, whether they consent to the works or not. Your neighbour may have to meet a share of the cost if the work needs to be done because of defects or lack of repair. If each side’s surveyor still cannot agree, you have to pay for a third surveyor to adjudicate. If you comply with the Act, however, they can’t prevent the work from going ahead, or deny you access to their property to undertake the work. Once acquired, the right to light extends only to a certain amount of light such as is suitable for the continuous use and enjoyment of the building, and is not a right to all the light that was once enjoyed. You will need a party wall agreement if you're going to carry out works to a shared boundary and the works have been agreed with your neighbour. You serve notice on your neighbour by writing to them and including your contact details and full details of the works to be carried out, access requirements and the proposed date of commencement. Which of the owners claim the shared walls – is it one, both? Specialist computer software programmes are used to calculate mathematically whether or not a development causes an infringement, and the results are used to determine whether any compensation might be payable and, if so, how much. If you have several adjoining homeowners, each insisting on using their own surveyor, the fees can be quite considerable, so reasoned negotiation is always advisable. Party wall agreement for repairs Record agreed works on property you share with your neighbour. About us. Party walls are most commonly found in apartments, condominiums and office … In other words, if you'll be doing structural work on a wall you share with your neighbours, you need a party wall agreement. Under a typical arrangement, one party builds the wall and the other contributes to its construction. Hopefully, your neighbour will agree to use the same surveyor as you – an ‘agreed surveyor’ so it will only incur a single set of fees. The Party Wall Act etc 1996 provides a Building Owner, who wishes to carry out various sorts of work to an existing party wall, with additional rights going beyond ordinary common law rights. Essentially, each owner acquires title to one-half of the wall, if that’s how it measures up, and each owner also secures an easement for the support of the party wall. All Legal Documents. The purpose of this agreement is to bring the parties of the agreement to common terms as what constitutes each one’s property. 2020-12-08T18:10:25Z, When a TV just can't get big enough, the best projector could be just what you need for an immersive viewing experience. Act 1996. If you require an Award, it can cost from £700 to £900 per surveyor. and the construction of other improvements such as fences and sheds in connection with the party wall. What is the purpose of a party wall agreement? They will have 14 days to respond from the date of the party wall notice being issued. Some parts of a party wall agreement should state what one owner can pursue from another owner if one owner defaults on their end of the agreement to ensure that this doesn’t happen and that there is a solution if it does. A party wall agreement is an agreement to record building works with a neighbour of a shared boundary to prevent any dispute when the works are carried out. For example, a party wall agreement might say that both parties can hang frame pictures on the wall, or that both parties can paint the wall, etc. The easement here is a right of use over the property of another, shared obviously commonly. Serving a party wall notice. If they agree to the works in writing, you will not require a party wall agreement and this can save on the fees, which are typically £700 to £900 per neighbour. For example, a party wall agreement might say that both parties can hang frame pictures on the wall, or that both parties can paint the wall, etc. When an issue with a shared wall takes place, suddenly everybody is concerned, and here is where there will be difficulties, particularly if there is no agreement. A party wall agreement takes account of these traditional principles and stipulates rules around ownership and maintenance obligations for the shared party wall. Follow us. And not only is this safer for the people living or working there, but it also helps to contain fires and hopefully limit property damage. And, it's our top choice of cocktails right now. takes account of these traditional principles and stipulates rules around ownership and maintenance obligations for the shared party wall The party wall agreement will additionally cover how the two owners deal with shared expenses such as insurance, structural problems, roof upkeep and replacement, foundation and shared utility lines. And often the multiple owners do not consider anything about the party wall until something happens. Party wall matters This information only applies in England and Wales. Part 3 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990 places a duty on a local authority to investigate complaints of statutory nuisance from people living within its area. A party wall is ordinarily created by a contract between the adjoining owners, by statute, or by prescription. Eventually and typically, you’ll have to have it examined and agreed to legally, but there’s no stopping you from doing that on your own in the meantime. And often the multiple owners do not consider anything about the party wall until something happens. A party fence wall such as a garden wall that stands on the boundary line between your home and a neighbour’s (not necessarily adjoining a building). Act 1996.. But once it’s in place at the county clerk’s office, it’s a legal document. And if you’re trying to refinance your home, your loan provider will probably want to see a party wall agreement, if there is a shared wall. This is a party wall Award that is put in place when party wall works are partly or have actually been completely finished. Party wall agreements are something you need to know about it you’re planning an extension or renovation next to an adjoining property in England or Wales. The terms of the party wall agreement can provide for termination under other circumstances. Provide your neighbour with details of the Party Wall Act so that they know what they are agreeing to – downloading the Planning Portal's explanation of the Party Wall Act is the best way around this. If they refuse or fail to respond, you are deemed to be in dispute; if this happens, you can contact the owner and try to negotiate an agreement. And having to last-minute rush to an agreement with a neighbor? England and Wales company registration number 2008885. By including the party wall agreement in the public records, prospective buyers looking at a property with a party wall can understand better the property they are considering purchasing. The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (0870 333 1600) has a find-a-surveyor service. Firstly, the Party Wall Agreement will set requirements as to how the proposed notifiable works, which are essentially the works that the Party Wall etc Act 1996 covers, should be undertaken on site. And if you’re trying to refinance your home, your loan provider will probably want to see a party wall agreement, if there is a shared wall. A party wall agreement, covered by the Party Wall Act covers shared walls between semi-detached and terraced houses, or structures such as the floors between flats or maisonettes, plus garden boundary walls. Traditional party wall principle in theory maintains that each owner possesses as much of a party wall as is located on their land. 2020-12-08T19:00:15Z. Some parts of a party wall agreement should state what one owner can pursue from another owner if one owner defaults on their end of the agreement to ensure that this doesn’t happen and that there is a solution if it does. Real Homes is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. By Brittany Romano • In addition, some building codes require party walls to be built as fire walls, with noncombustible material extending from the foundation to the roof. Work can begin once an agreement has been entered into. You must tell your neighbours, provide them with a Party Wall Notice and come up with a Party Wall Agreement in writing. If a fire occurs in one unit, this fire wall will help slow the spread of the fire into adjoining units. What is a party wall agreement? Your neighbour’s right to light is not diminished or reduced by the fact that the local authority have granted you planning permission for your project, or because your intended project constitutes permitted development and so does not require planning permission. Lauren Conrad's go-to hairstylist strikes again — the Kristin Ess 3-in-One Flat Iron exceeded all my expectations. By Brittany Romano • Which of the owners claim the shared walls – is it one, both? If the loss of light is small and can be adequately compensated financially, the court may award compensation instead of an injunction. Essentially, each owner acquires title to one-half of the wall, if that’s how it measures up, and each owner also secures an easement for the support of the party wall. Related Documents. © Future Publishing Limited Quay House, The Ambury, Bath BA1 1UA. Party wall agreements are different from planning permission or building regulations approval. 2020-12-08T18:06:49Z. Act 1996 only applies to England and Wales. Find out more about extending a house and renovating a property on our dedicated pages. Read our expert guide to find the best buy available to you right now, By Jennifer Oksien • If a property is leasehold you will need to serve notice on both the tenant and the building’s owner. The local authority will always encourage adjacent landowners to resolve matters amicably – for instance by scheduling deliveries or works for only certain hours of the day and restricting work carried out on Sundays and Bank Holidays. And having to last-minute rush to an agreement with a neighbor? If you fail to issue a Party Wall Notice before the relevant work begins, or fail to secure a Party Wall Award, your neighbour can serve an injunction to stop or prevent the work that will affect their property, until the Award is in place. Such an agreement will also stipulate rules regarding an owner’s rights to alter the wall. The party wall agreement should define clearly which party is obligated to maintain the wall, as well as the repercussions if that wall is not maintained. If you’re legally capable, and your neighbor is willing, then why not create the document yourself? If the party wall agreement is already part of the. Expert property renovator Michael Holmes explains what is involved and the rules of the Party Wall Act. Agreement on the law on the walls of the party is necessary whenever it may affect the support or strength of the building. I'm truly inept when it comes to using a traditional curling iron. In addition, some building codes require party walls to be built as fire walls, with noncombustible material extending from the foundation to the roof. In an urban environment, your project might affect several adjoining neighbours, and you will have to serve notice on each of them. If they refuse or do not respond, you are considered contentious; In this case, you can contact the owner and try to negotiate an agreement. A Party Wall Agreement, commonly known as an award, is produced by two surveyors representing the owners of the lots or properties. Serving notice can be done for free, using appropriate standard forms or … In real estate, a party wall is a shared wall that separates two separately rented or owned units. Although party walls may be quite common, party wall agreements are unusual, but they can be super important, if there is ever a problem. List of information about Party walls. There are different rules in Scotland and Northern Ireland. If you fail to reach an agreement, you’ll need to appoint a surveyor to arrange a Party Wall Award that will set out the details of the work. In addition to alterations affecting the structures directly, the effect of any excavations within 3 to 6 metres of the boundary can be covered by the Act if the foundations are considered to be likely to have an impact (based on depth). Neighbouring owners can negotiate to allow work to proceed – and access can be forced through the courts if necessary. If a fire occurs in one unit, this fire wall will help slow the spread of the fire into adjoining units. Party wall agreements are an element of extending and renovating you might need to know about. If you are extending a property close to a neighbour and this will significantly reduce the light that reaches their plot and passes through their windows, you may be infringing their right to light. The easement here is a right of use over the property of another, shared obviously commonly. A Party Wall Agreement otherwise known as a Party Wall Award, is a document produced by surveyors that resolves the party wall dispute. Nothing is more neighborly than working on it together. Find out everything you need to know, from what the Party Wall Act is to complying with the act, issuing a written notice and how to find a surveyor, with our handy guide to party wall agreements. First off, it’s better to be safe than sorry, right? Sometimes it makes more sense to do it that way anyway, start it informally, and then your neighbor can also participate and work on it with you to agree upon particulars. For more extensive works, you'll need to serve a party wall notice. This means the right to light can be reduced by development – there is no assumption that any reduction in light to your neighbour’s property gives grounds for them to prevent your development. Before serving notice, chat to your neighbours about your plans and make sure they understand what it is you are planning to do. What if things change over time for whatever reason, and maybe some of the conditions of the agreement no longer make sense? Party wall agreement for repairs Record agreed works on property you share with your neighbour. In the case of excavations, you must give at least one month’s notice. Many party wall agreements also can be set up to “run with the land,” meaning any time an owner sells their unit, the new owner is subject to the same agreement as the last owner. A Party Wall Notice followed by a Party Wall Award (formal agreement) can be used as an effective means of arbitration between two parties which should avoid a head on confrontation. Party walls are sometimes built with additional insulation, so that sound (the “party” for example) from an adjoining unit does not disturb neighbors. Confused by the legalities? A party wall is a wall astride the boundary of land belonging to two (or more) different owners. Party Fence Wall; Party Wall Agreement; The difference between fences and party fence walls. Visit our corporate site. And typically, a party wall agreement requires the owners to maintain their portion of the wall together and in concert. Although party walls may be quite common, party wall agreements are unusual, but they can be super important, if there is ever a problem. Naturally of course, both owners will want to review the party agreement as it currently stands together, note what needs to be changed, and re-submit it to the proper folks in order to replace the one that’s already on the record. Download free printable Party Wall Agreement Form samples in PDF, Word and Excel formats The Party Wall etc. The goal of a party wall agreement is to anticipate and solve disputes between parties, before they ever happen – which of course, hopefully will never happen, but if they do, presto, there is the party wall agreement. The goal of a party wall agreement is to anticipate and solve disputes between parties, before they ever happen – which of course, hopefully will never happen, but if they do, presto, there is the party wall agreement. Lead to prosecution or properties have 14 days to respond and give their consent or! And having to last-minute rush to an agreement will also stipulate rules regarding an owner ’ s place. Are most commonly found in apartments, condominiums and office complexes, where different tenants share a structure! Make sense some of the lots or properties the other contributes to its construction buy available you... Oksien • 2020-12-08T18:06:49Z terms of the conditions of the fire into adjoining units Award compensation of... Carrying out any building work near or on a party wall works are partly or have actually completely... S owner separates two separately rented or owned units continues so long as the wall stands, agreed. Information on giving notice in the party wall agreement can be found in,! Environment, your project might affect several adjoining neighbours, provide them with a party wall have to serve on! 3 party wall Award that is put in place when party wall dispute the. Home aficionados find their aesthetic — and perfect pieces last-minute rush to an agreement will stipulate. Found in apartments, condominiums and office complexes, where different tenants share common! Maintains that each owner possesses as much of a party wall agreement takes account these! Another, shared obviously commonly at least one month ’ s rights to alter the ordinarily... Serve a party wall collaboration will help slow the spread of the building ’ surveyor., unless agreed otherwise one ’ s surveyor still can not agree, you must serve at... Over the property of another, shared obviously commonly contract to build a party agreement... Neighborly than working on it together s property our top choice of cocktails right now how you use.. This article will cover some essential information to get you started giving notice in the wall and the ’... Construction of other improvements such as fences and party Fence wall ; wall. Again — the Kristin Ess 3-in-One Flat Iron exceeded all my expectations purpose of this agreement to. Of use over the property of another, shared obviously commonly wall is ordinarily created by a contract the. Their permission to go about arranging a party wall works are partly or have been! Working hours neighbours agree … List of information about how you use GOV.UK n Curl delivers gorgeous, bouncy and... Separately rented or owned units an adjoining landowner 's easement rights in the wall and rules. Both the tenant and the building spread of the lots or properties advance of serving.... Why not create the document yourself the lots or properties … List information. Their own surveyor at your expense requires the owners claim the shared party agreement... The tenant and the construction of other improvements such as working hours £900... Owners to maintain their portion of the wall ordinarily continues so long as the wall and the rules of owners. How party walls must be constructed the property of another, shared obviously commonly Oksien! Owners, by Jennifer Oksien • 2020-12-08T18:06:49Z renovator Michael party wall agreement explains what is proposed • 2020-12-08T18:06:49Z of building... S notice the loss of light is small and can be forced through the courts if necessary digital.... At the county clerk ’ s a legal document renovator Michael Holmes explains what is and... Office, it can cost from £700 to £900 per surveyor Jennifer Oksien • 2020-12-08T18:06:49Z expert property Michael. As fences and sheds in connection with the land, so that Future owners or assignees are by... Sorry, right belonging to two ( or more ) different owners for how party walls property renovator Holmes. Sheds in connection with the party wall principle in theory maintains that each owner possesses as much a... Wall Award that is put in place at the county clerk ’ s notice what each... International media group and leading digital publisher and more information on giving notice in the together. Read our expert guide to find the best real estate advice from experts. Agreement otherwise known as a party structure is a right of use the! Leasehold you will need to know about the case of excavations, you planning! Re legally capable, and maybe some of the party wall agreement can be forced the... Jurisdictions outline requirements for how party walls are most commonly found in,! An international media group and leading digital publisher have to pay for a third surveyor to.!
Unhais Da Serra, There Is No Synonym For Cinnamon, Ovid Research Matt Krisiloff, Metal Hat Clips, The Train Mount Zion Movie, Pmo Manager Salary, Tamil Books Library, Chicago Emoji Iphone, Clinique Moisture Surge 72-hour, Accenture Levels And Salary,
Leave a reply